This game is named after Commissioner Grisaffi, the fourth AAYFL commissioner. Commissioner Grisaffi brought organization, process, and discipline to the league during a time of explosive growth and his contributions to the success of the AAYFL will not be forgotten.
| YEAR | GC | WINNING TEAM | SCORE | LOSING TEAM | SCORE | NOTES |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | XL | Whitnall | 42 | Cudahy | 18 | Most Combined Points |
| 2015 | XXXVIIII | Wauwatosa East | 30 | Cudahy | 8 | Inaugural Class B Championship |